When creating a GUI wizard, should all pages/tabs be of the same size? [closed]
Posted
by
Job
on Programmers
See other posts from Programmers
or by Job
Published on 2011-01-12T22:24:58Z
Indexed on
2011/01/12
22:58 UTC
Read the original article
Hit count: 205
gui-design
|wizard
I understand that some libraries would force me to, but my question is general.
If I have a set of buttons at the bottom: Back, Next, Cancel?, (other?), then should their location ever change? If the answer is no, then what do I do about pages with little content? Do I stretch things? Place them in the lone upper left corner? According to Steve Krug, it does not make sense to add anything to GUI that does not need to be there.
I understand that there are different approaches to wizards - some have tabs, others do not. Some tabs are lined horizontally at the top; others - vertically on the left. Some do not show pages/tabs, and are simply sequences of dialogs. This is probably a must when the wizard is "non-linear", e.g. some earlier choices can result in branching.
Either way the problem is the same - sacrifice on the consistency of the "big picture" (outline of the page/tab + location of buttons), or the consistency of details (some tabs might be somewhat packed; others having very little content). A third choice, I suppose is putting extra effort in the content in order to make sure that organizing the content such that it is more or less evenly distributed from page to page. However, this can be difficult to do (say, when the very first tab contains only a choice of three things, and then branches off from there; there are probably other examples), and hard to maintain this balance if any of the content changes later.
Can you recommend a good approach? A link to a relevant good blog post or a chapter of a book is also welcome.
Let me know if you have questions.
© Programmers or respective owner